Timing Your Trade-In
At some point, every driver starts thinking about their next vehicle, asking, “Should I trade in my current car now, or wait a little longer?” At Carlisle Buick GMC, we’ve helped folks from all over the area get the most for their trade-ins, and the truth is, over time, it makes a big difference. Whether you’re still making payments or just curious if your car is at the right mileage to hold strong value, we are here to walk you through what matters when deciding the best time to trade in a car. Visit us today in Carlisle, PA, and become aware of the best strategies for maximizing your trade-in value!
Why Timing Matters
Your car’s value doesn’t just depend on its make, model, or condition, but also on when you trade it in. Market demand, interest rates, seasonal trends, mileage benchmark, and even new model release dates can all influence your car’s trade-in value, and having access to this information can make a significant difference. At Carlisle Buick GMC, we always recommend that customers evaluate three main factors when deciding the best time to trade in a car: loan status, your vehicle’s age and mileage, and the current used vehicle market.
When Is The Best Time To Trade In A Car You Still Owe Money On?
If you’re still making payments, the best time to trade in a car becomes even more critical. The key here is understanding equity. If your car is worth more than what you owe, you have positive equity and can apply that value to your next vehicle. If you owe more than your car is worth, that’s negative equity, and you’ll need to either pay the difference or roll it into your next loan.
Early In The Loan
Typically, you’ll have negative equity in the first one to two years of a loan due to depreciation. Unless your vehicle has high demand or low mileage, trading in this early may cost you.
Mid-Loan Sweet Spot
Ideally, years three to four of your loan are often the best time to trade in a car. Your loan balance has dropped, depreciation has slowed, and you may now have positive equity.
End of the Loan
At this point, your car’s value has likely decreased significantly, but if it’s in good condition, you could still trade it in and get solid value before costly repairs creep in.
We advise our customers to check their payoff balance and request a trade-in appraisal from our team at Carlisle Buick GMC to see how the numbers stack up.
How Long Should You Keep A Car Before Trading It In?
While the answer to the best time to trade in a car varies depending on your driving habits and financial goals, most experts and our own trade-in data suggest that three to five years is the sweet spot for many vehicles. By year three, depreciation begins to level off, and you might have positive equity. After year five, the risk of maintenance costs increases significantly. Trading within that three-to-five-year window often means that you’re maximizing value while still driving a reliable, relatively modern vehicle. If you’re nearing that range, come visit us for a free appraisal. Even if you decide to hold on to your car longer, it helps to have the numbers in hand.
Best Mileage To Trade In A Car
Just like age, your car’s mileage can make or break your trade-in value. Knowing the best time to trade in a car depends on how far you’ve driven it.
Under 30,000 Miles
This mileage range is premium territory. Cars under 30,000 miles fetch the highest trade-in values, especially if maintained well, allowing you to enjoy the benefits of a higher trade-in value.
30,000 to 60,000 Miles
This is an excellent range, especially for vehicles with strong reliability records. Most powertrain warranties are still active here, making it easier to trade in your vehicle.
60,000 to 100,000 Miles
Value starts to taper off here. Major components like brakes, tires, and timing belts are nearing replacement age, which can cost you more money in the long run.
Over 100,000 Miles
While not necessarily a deal breaker, most vehicles in this range see a significant value drop, especially if they show wear.
So if your car is sitting at 58,000 miles and you’re thinking about trading up, now might be the right time to get top dollar before crossing that next threshold and seeing a lower return.
How Soon Can You Trade In A Car?
Technically, you can trade in a vehicle the day you drive it off the lot, but whether it makes financial sense is another story. Immediate trade-ins are possible, but you should expect steep depreciation, as new cars typically lose 20 to 30% of their value in the first year.
Six Months to One Year
This is often still too soon unless you have a rare, high-demand model. The earlier you trade, the more likely you’ll carry negative equity into your next purchase, so choosing the best time to trade in a car is subject to careful consideration of your financial situation.
Two to Three Years
Ideally, this is when trading in starts to make more financial sense, especially if you financed with a short-term loan or paid a large down payment.
The earlier you trade, the more likely you’ll carry negative equity into your next purchase, so choosing the best time to trade in a car is crucial if you want to upgrade without increasing your debt.
Should I Pay Off My Car Before Trading It In?
Waiting can make sense if you’re close to paying off your loan. However, you don’t have to pay off your loan before trading it in, as many of our customers at Carlisle Buick GMC trade in their cars with outstanding balances all the time. If your car is worth more than your payoff amount, meaning it’s in positive equity, the surplus reduces your next loan or can be used as a down payment. If you are stuck in negative equity, you can roll the remaining balance into your new loan, but this can increase your monthly payments, so it’s best to use it carefully.
Get Your Trade-In Value At Carlisle Buick GMC
Ultimately, the best time to trade in a car depends on your individual situation: what you owe, your car’s mileage, its condition, and your goals. At Carlisle Buick GMC, we make the process of trading in your car simple, providing you with a fast, accurate trade-in appraisal and a walkthrough of your equity position, and we offer top dollar for your current vehicle, whether you’re still making payments or have your car paid off. Looking to upgrade to a new GMC Terrain or Buick Enclave? Let’s get started with a complimentary trade-in evaluation. We’re here to help you get the most for your current ride and the most excitement out of your next one. Visit us today in Carlisle, PA!
Connect with us
